Auto InsuranceGames

The Best South Dakota Auto Insurance Companies in 2019

The Best South Dakota Auto Insurance Companies in 2019

The Best South Dakota Auto Insurance Companies

South Dakota’s low population density keeps its common auto insurance premium at a mere $767 per yr— that’s one of many lowest rates in the nation. However you could not find it so reasonably priced when you’ve got a less-than-perfect driving report. The excellent news is, it’s nonetheless attainable to seek out an incredible deal on your insurance. Begin with our rundown of one of the best auto insurance providers in South Dakota, after which use our quote device to see what every of them can give you.

How We Found the Best South Dakota Auto Insurance Companies

We rated the most effective auto insurance coverage providers in South Dakota utilizing a strategy just like the one in our nationwide auto insurance assessment. We began by specializing in the most important insurers in the state by market share. Then, we checked with unbiased financial scores businesses like A.M. Best to ensure that these corporations would have the ability to pay out their claims if vital.

After that, we seemed into coverage choices, coverage limits, and discounts. We made positive that every company we advocate presents all the protections a South Dakota driver might want, plus plenty of ways to keep costs down. We also took buyer opinion under consideration, wanting on the newest J.D. Power and Shopper Reviews surveys to assess how nicely each firm lived as much as its advertising promises. Then, simply to make certain, we examined a number of online quotes for ourselves.

The 6 Best Auto Insurance Companies in South Dakota

South Dakota Auto Insurance Critiques

State Farm

State Farm makes an look in our roundup of the most effective nationwide providers, and for good purpose. Not solely does it write probably the most auto policies in South Dakota, it also boasts one of many highest scores for financial stability. With an “A++” from A.M. Best, you possibly can rest assured State Farm is able to pay out any declare.

When it comes to buyer satisfaction, State Farm brings in a strong 89/100 from Shopper Stories, with “excellent” marks in “ease of reaching an agent,” “timely payments,” and “agent courtesy.” J.D. Energy provides it an “average” rating (three out of five) and 824/1,000 for the region. This implies most people are usually happy with the service.

State Farm’s reductions for South Dakota drivers are respectable, but a tad slimmer than other corporations on this listing. When you’ll find several discounts for car safety and an option to enroll in its Drive Protected and Save program — which, by the best way, might earn you up to 50% off your coverage — you gained’t find reductions for seniors, being a loyal buyer, or proudly owning a brand new automotive.

While State Farm makes a name for itself in our nationwide assessment for offering rideshare coverage to the vast majority of the U.S., South Dakota just isn’t on the record. So in the event you’re an Uber or Lyft driver in the Mount Rushmore State, you may need to take a look at Progressive.

We also hit a small roadblock when making an attempt to test State Farm’s on-line quote software. You’re required to enter either your Social Safety or driver’s license quantity — neither of which we felt snug getting into for a check. In case you’d quite not enter that info on-line, you possibly can all the time contact an agent for assistance.


Progressive is another strong choice for South Dakota residents. It fares nicely in the financial stability realm, with an “A+” from A.M. Best. It also earns an 87/100 from Shopper Stories — which is about common — with “excellent” scores for its timely claims payments. That stated, Progressive ranks under common with J.D. Power, scoring just two out of five Energy Circles.

Scores apart, Progressive stands out for a couple causes. At first are its generous discount choices — together with financial savings for getting an internet quote, signing on-line, paying in full, and “continuous insurance” (which means they’ll rely your time with a earlier insurer in the direction of your loyalty low cost). Progressive is understood for being friendly in the direction of “riskier” drivers, and even provides discounts for teens (18 years or younger).

This firm exhibits up in terms of protection, too. You’ll find accident forgiveness (should you’re a more moderen customer — your first claim beneath $500 gained’t increase your fee), and a singular custom elements coverage choice. Progressive also presents ridesharing coverage in South Dakota. Uber and Lyft drivers can embrace that info in the web quote course of to see how a lot the added coverage will value. Simply observe this can shift your limits and pricing a bit, as Uber/Lyft drivers are required to carry greater legal responsibility limits of at the least 50/100/25.

Talking of quotes, we found Progressive’s on-line system to be easy and straightforward to navigate. We have been capable of get a quote in less than ten minutes. Progressive additionally provides you three totally different choices in terms of pricing and protection, making it a breeze to see how a lot protection matches within your price range. Additionally, if you want to begin the whole quote course of with a desired worth in thoughts, Progressive’s Identify Your Worth Software permits you to do exactly that.

American Household Insurance

American Family is the third largest auto insurer in South Dakota, and boasts robust scores for buyer expertise. Shopper Studies provides it an 89/100, with “excellent” marks for “ease of reaching an agent,” “timely payment,” and “agent courtesy.” When it comes to financial stability, it’s barely decrease than our different contenders, with an “A” from A.M. Best (still a very good rating, simply not as rock strong as State Farm’s “A++”).

We respect that AmFam’s web site is straightforward to navigate. You’re more likely to find all of the auto insurance information you want, especially with the help of its in depth blog. American Household also provides a reside chat choice and 24/7 buyer help by way of telephone, each of that are extremely helpful when you have got questions or need claims assistance outdoors of normal enterprise hours. On prime of that, AmFam is likely one of the few corporations that allows you to search for protection requirements by state. This can be useful when determining how much insurance coverage you want.

It’s value noting that American Household presents probably the most reductions out of all our contenders, too. From protected driving, safety gear, and age-based reductions, to financial savings for driving underneath 7,500 miles in a yr, AmFam makes saving money in your coverage fairly reachable.

It also supplies a strong listing of supplemental protection, including hole insurance and rental reimbursement. Heads up, though: Uber and Lyft drivers gained’t have the ability to purchase rideshare protection by means of American Household in South Dakota.


Nationwide falls in the center of the pack so far as scores go. Shopper Studies provides it an 88/100 with “excellent” marks for agent courtesy — about common when considering the opposite gamers on this page. J.D. Power provides it a lower rating, two out of five, for the central area of the U.S., however A.M. Best provides it an “A+” for monetary stability. Whereas these scores aren’t across-the-board stellar, they’re indicative of a dependable company general.

We have been especially impressed with Nationwide’s coverage choices — together with rental automotive reimbursement, hole protection, accident forgiveness, and a vanishing deductible. Slightly totally different than Progressive’s Deductible Financial savings Bank, Nationwide permits you to shave $100 off your deductible every year you drive without an accident, for up to $500.

Nationwide isn’t fairly as strong in the discount area as a few of our different contenders, however it does supply a couple of easy-to-reach ones, like going paperless or having anti-theft units installed in your automotive. The insurer additionally offers a service that will help you ensure you’re maximizing coverage and reductions. Referred to as the On Your Aspect Assessment, Nationwide offers you one free session per yr with the intention to make sure you’re getting probably the most out of your insurance coverage.

Once we tried to tug a quote for our Sioux Falls check profile, we have been directed to talk with an agent. Although you’ll have to speak with an agent ultimately — once you’re ready to purchase a policy — we want corporations that give you the freedom to match prices on your own first.


Farmers boasts strong scores in the customer service realm, with an 89/100 on Shopper Studies and a 3 out of 5 Power Circles from J.D. Power’s regional evaluation. When it comes to monetary stability, Farmers holds a robust — however not exceptional — “A” from A.M. Best.

One factor that did stand out was Farmers website, which makes it straightforward to seek out all the knowledge you want when researching insurance policies. For instance, coverage choices we seemed for like new automotive alternative, accident forgiveness, and customised gear coverage have been clearly listed. (Although we noted the shortage of ridesharing coverage in South Dakota.)

We might additionally see that Farmers has all kinds of discounts, together with one for teen drivers, being employed or retired from an accredited business, or driving a automotive with eco-friendly gasoline options. Should you’re 55 or older and complete a protected driver program authorised by Farmers, you would qualify for a reduction, too.

Like Nationwide, Farmers denied us a quote on-line, as an alternative directing us to contact an area company and converse with a representative. Once more, that is solely a small setback — however it makes the quote comparison course of slightly more time-consuming.


USAA is the probably the most highly-regarded insurer on this listing. With an “A++” from A.M. Best, there’s absolutely no want to worry about USAA’s potential to pay out on claims. USAA takes residence gold for customer support, too: Shopper Reviews provides it a 95/100 and “excellent” marks in each class, while J.D. Power provides it 906/1,000 in the area and a rare 5 out of five Energy Circles. It’s clear that South Dakotans are proud of their USAA insurance coverage.

So what’s the catch? USAA is just out there to present or former army members and their households. When you have served, are presently serving, or have close kin in the army, we highly recommend getting a quote from USAA. Together with stellar customer support scores, the company presents a strong listing of protection and discounts, and is understood for saving army members money on their automotive insurance coverage.

Information to South Dakota Auto Insurance Companies

South Dakota minimum automotive insurance coverage necessities

By regulation, every driver in South Dakota has to carry liability insurance coverage in case they cause an accident. With a purpose to drive legally it’s essential to have at the very least:

  • $25,000 bodily damage protection per individual
  • $50,000 bodily damage coverage per accident
  • $25,000 property injury protection per accident

South Dakota can also be one of many few states that requires you to carry uninsured and underinsured motorist protection in the same quantities listed above ($25,000/$50,000). These shield you in case you’re hit by another driver who doesn’t have insurance coverage or who doesn’t have enough to cover the complete extent of the damages.

Automotive repairs are expensive in South Dakota

Should you’re in a critical accident, you possibly can anticipate to pay a number of grand a minimum of to get your automotive fastened. The most up-to-date knowledge obtainable on auto restore prices — carried out by the NAIC — discovered that South Dakota residents had the fifth highest average auto restore prices in the nation.

Ensure you have collision and complete protection on your car, even in the event you aren’t required to buy it by your lender. These add-ons will assist pay for repairs after an accident — however they’ll additionally cowl you in instances of theft, vandalism, natural disaster, and so forth. That means, no matter what happens, you gained’t have to fret about paying for repairs out of pocket.

South Dakota Auto Insurance FAQ

What are average auto insurance coverage rates in South Dakota?

In accordance with the Nationwide Association of Insurance Commissioners’ latest report, auto insurance costs around $767 per yr for South Dakotans. That’s far under the nationwide common of $1,009. The truth is, in line with newer knowledge provided by The Zebra, residents dwelling in the Great Plains are likely to take pleasure in lower auto insurance rates than the remainder of the nation.

What makes auto insurance charges in South Dakota so low?

South Dakota has one of many lowest population densities in the country. On prime of that, its drivers spend the least amount of time on the street. Insurers love to hear that as a result of fewer drivers and less time spent on the street means a lower probability of accidents. Another perk of having such a low inhabitants density is that there are fewer automotive thefts in the state. As a result of insurers don’t need to pay out on these claims typically, they’re prepared to offer South Dakota residents a lower fee on their premiums.

How much coverage do I want?

It’s all the time greatest to buy greater than the state minimum coverage, in the event you can afford to do so. Say that you simply cause $50,000 in property damages. When you go together with minimum coverage, your insurance coverage will solely pay for half of that, leaving you to provide you with the remaining by yourself — a troublesome (and costly) position to seek out yourself wading by way of. Thankfully, it’s straightforward to avoid this state of affairs by buying as a lot liability protection as you’ll be able to comfortably afford.

How can I know I’m getting the most effective deal on my auto insurance?

You’ll find an awesome deal on auto insurance coverage by doing slightly comparison purchasing. Every company weighs the varied elements of your software in a different way, which is why they all offer you totally different quotes. Begin with the six corporations we’ve reviewed, and put aside some time to match what every provides in phrases of choices and pricing — then go together with the one that provides you with probably the most coverage for the perfect worth.

The Best South Dakota Auto Insurance Companies: Summed Up