blog cosmic horror Games H.P. Lovecraft H.P. Lovecraft Reread Mariana Enriquez Megan McDowel Things We Lost in the Fire Under the Black Water

Shadow Over Argentina: Mariana Enriquez’s “Under the Black Water”

Shadow Over Argentina: Mariana Enriquez’s “Under the Black Water”

Welcome again to the Lovecraft reread, through which two trendy Mythos writers get woman cooties throughout previous Howard’s sandbox, from those that impressed him to those that have been impressed in flip.

As we speak we’re studying Mariana Enriquez’s “Under the Black Water,” first revealed in English in Issues We Misplaced in the Hearth, translated by Megan McDowel. Spoilers forward.

“She dreamed that when the boy emerged from the water and shook off the muck, the fingers fell off his hands.”


Marina Pinat, Buenos Aires DA, isn’t thrilled with the smug cop sitting in her workplace. He hasn’t introduced a lawyer—in any case, he says, he’s harmless. By no means thoughts that Pinat has his voice on tape, saying “Problem solved. They learned how to swim.” The time stamp means that he at the least knew that two younger males have been thrown into the Ricachuelo River. However then, that kind of factor occurs so much in the Villa Moreno slum, and convictions are few.

Yamil Corvalán’s physique has already washed up, a kilometer from the bridge. He tried to swim by means of the black grease that covers the river, holds it “calm and dead.” He drowned when he might not transfer his arms. The physique of Emanuel López, the second boy, nonetheless hasn’t surfaced.

I didn’t do it, the cop says. However nonetheless: If solely that entire slum would go up in flames. You haven’t any concept what goes on there.

However Pinat does, and doesn’t attempt to examine the slum from her desk like a few of her colleagues. Just some months in the past, she helped win a case towards a tannery that dumped poisonous waste in the river for many years, inflicting an enormous cluster of childhood cancers and start defects: additional arms, cat-like noses, blind high-set eyes. She met Father Francisco, who advised her that nobody even got here to church.

After the cop leaves, a pregnant teenager is available in, demanding a reward for details about Emanuel. He’s in Villa Moreno. He got here out of the water. He’s solely been again a short while. And he needs to satisfy Pinat. Perhaps the woman is mendacity? In any case, a dwelling boy is one much less crime to accuse the cops of. However the subsequent day, when she tries to name individuals in the slum, none of her contacts reply. So, time to go away her desk and examine.

On the southern fringe of the metropolis, previous the Moreno Bridge, the metropolis frays into deserted buildings and rusted indicators. Past this empty space reside the metropolis’s poor by the hundreds. The slum spreads alongside the black river, to the limits of imaginative and prescient. The river itself has been the chosen dumping website for waste from cow offal up by way of the tanner’s heavy metals. Her father, who as soon as labored on a River Barge, informed tales of the water operating purple. Its stench, he stated, was brought on by its lack of oxygen. The river’s lifeless, unable to breathe.

The driving force makes her stroll the final 300 meters; the lifeless boys’ lawyer gained’t come in any respect. Pinat’s dressed down from her regular DA fits, and carries solely sufficient cash to get residence and a cellphone handy muggers if wanted. And her gun, in fact.

In the Villa, she’s startled by silence. Usually there’s music, bikes, scorching grills, individuals speaking. Usually there are individuals. However now the streets are lifeless as the river. Ultimately, nonetheless unable to succeed in anybody, she tries to seek out her option to Father Francisco’s church. She acknowledges that little yellow home, so she’s not misplaced. However behind her, footsteps squelch: certainly one of the deformed youngsters. She’s disturbed by his toothless mouth and sucker-like fingers. He passes her, gliding towards the church.

The church has been painted yellow, adorned with a crown of flowers, and the partitions are coated with graffiti: YAINGNGAHYOGSOTHOTHHEELGEBFAITHRODOG. (It’s the most exceptional phrase we’ve ever seen.) The boy opens the door; she goes in. And the church… is not a church. The chairs have been cleared out, together with the crucifix and the photographs of Jesus and Our Woman. As an alternative there’s a picket pool topped with a freshly slaughtered cow’s head. Hallelujah?

You shouldn’t have come, says Father Francisco. He’s emaciated, soiled, his hair overgrown and greasy. Additionally he’s very, very drunk. “In his house,” says the boy, “the dead man waits dreaming.” The priest is livid, and livid with Pinat for being silly sufficient to return.

In the distance, she hears drums. She’s relieved—clearly, everybody has simply gone to follow the murga for carnival, or already began to rejoice just a little early. The cow’s head, clearly, is simply a few of the neighborhood drug sellers making an attempt to intimidate the priest.

It’s a must to get out of right here, Pinat tells him. He laughs. He’s tried! However he’s not getting out, and neither is she. “That boy woke up the thing sleeping under the water. Don’t you hear them?” For years, he says, he thought the rotted river an indication of ineptitude. However now he is aware of: they have been making an attempt to cowl one thing up, hold it from getting out. However the police throwing individuals in there, that was silly. Individuals swimming underneath the black water, they woke the factor up. “Emanuel” means “god is with us.” However what god?

Pinat’s doubtful about all this, or needs to be. By no means thoughts how the priest is aware of she’s there about Emanuel, or is aware of about the pregnant woman who pointed her this manner. She tries to get them out of there, and he grabs her gun. Earlier than she will react, he shoots himself. She leaves the church crying and shaking.

The Villa’s not empty any extra; the drums are passing in entrance of the church. It’s no murga, however a shambling procession. Amongst the youngsters marked by the black water, she thinks she spots the cop, violating his home arrest. They’re carrying a mattress, with some human effigy mendacity on it. She’s making an attempt to get a glimpse when the factor strikes, and its grey arm falls over the aspect. Then she runs, making an attempt to disregard the agitation of the water that ought to have the ability to breathe, or transfer. And it undoubtedly shouldn’t be swelling. She runs, not wanting again, and covers her ears towards the sound of the drums.

What’s Cyclopean: That is very a lot a place-as-character story. In the slum Buenos Aires “frays” into deserted storefronts, and an oil-filled river “decomposes” into “dangerous and deliberate putrescence.”

The Degenerate Dutch: The river’s air pollution causes delivery defects. The youngsters born with these defects are, alas, handled extra as symbols than characters, or as indications that the river leaches humanity. The priest refers to them as “retards,” however the narrative itself isn’t doing a lot better.

Mythos Making: The graffiti on the church consists of the identify “Yog Sothoth” amid its seeming gobbledygook. In the meantime, “in his house, the dead man waits dreaming.” So what’s prisoned underneath the river?

Libronomicon: No books this week.

Insanity Takes Its Toll: Father Francisco doesn’t deal with his parishioners’ new religion nicely. TW for suicide.


Anne wasn’t capable of submit a commentary this week. Her absence is completely not because of nefarious extraterrestrial body-snatching, we promise.


Ruthanna’s Commentary

I’ve been eager to learn extra bizarre fiction in translation, so was excited to select up Mariana Enriquez’s Issues We Misplaced in the Hearth. Translation is its personal artwork, in fact, and je ne parle pas Espanol, so the story I’ve truly learn could also be as a lot the work of Megan McDowel as Enriquez. Both means, it’s good to learn a narrative with totally different settings from our standard choice, totally different factors of view, totally different horrors. Properly, perhaps not all the time that final. I swear we don’t maintain choosing tales with shootings and killer cops intentionally. It’s simply that even the weirdest fiction wants a method to elide the seams between real-world horror and supernatural horror—and lots of authors have comparable observations about the former.

Enriquez’s seams are superb ones. A lot of “Black Water’s” horror is the surreal constraints of poverty, air pollution, and corrupt authority. After a couple of pages of that, strolling corpses and abomination-imprisoning oil slicks simply look like a logical extension. Defiled church buildings, shambling inhuman processions… hey. Hey, wait a second—does this sound acquainted to anybody else?

“Under the Black Water” isn’t fairly a “Shadow Over Innsmouth” retelling, however it riffs on the similar tune. Remoted locals take doubtful actions round a close-by physique of water, leading to youngsters “born wrong.” A brand new and suspicious faith drives Christianity from the group. There are hints of sacrifice, mysterious deaths of the younger. An outsider is available in to research, and finally flees a hazard by no means made absolutely clear. And in making an attempt to make these insular locals really terrifying, the narrative will get problematic as all hell.

Yeah, skip continents, and the tainted roots of horror will nonetheless get you. On this case somewhat than Lovecraft’s racism and terror of psychological sickness, we get ableism and a fun-sized dose of fat-phobia. I felt disagreeable echoes of “That Only a Mother,” a much-reprinted golden age SF story through which the surprising twist at the finish is that the in any other case precocious child hasn’t obtained any limbs (and, unintentionally, that the society in query hasn’t acquired a clue about prosthetics). Not one among the blind youngsters with misshapen arms will get characterization, or perhaps a talking position aside from to mouth platitudes about lifeless issues dreaming. As an alternative we get “deformed children with their skinny arms and mollusk fingers, followed by women, most of them fat, their bodies disfigured by a diet based on carbs.”

Physique horror based mostly on actual our bodies is horrible, however not essentially in the approach the writer needs.

I’m nonetheless intrigued by the concept of air pollution as a messed-up try at binding—containing, in fact, the seeds of its personal destruction. The air pollution, holding down no matter lies underneath the river, shapes the group, its youngsters, its resentment, till they burst forth into one thing that may stir the river and launch what lies beneath. Oh come, Emanuel? And naturally, no matter lies beneath the river may need been much less malevolent, if it hadn’t spent all that point bathing its ectoplasm in poisonous sludge. As it’s, the cow’s head, and the yellow–tainted cross and flowers, don’t promise a cheerful relationship, no matter who worships what.


Subsequent week, Lovecraft and Henry S. Whitehead clarify why you need to be extra cautious about mirrors in “The Trap.”

Ruthanna Emrys is the writer of the Innsmouth Legacy collection, together with Winter Tide and Deep Roots. Her neo-Lovecraftian tales “The Litany of Earth” and “Those Who Watch” can be found on, together with the distinctly non-Lovecraftian “Seven Commentaries on an Imperfect Land” and “The Deepest Rift.” Ruthanna can steadily be discovered on-line on Twitter and Dreamwidth, and offline in a mysterious manor home together with her giant, chaotic family—principally mammalian—outdoors Washington DC.

Anne M. Pillsworth’s brief story “The Madonna of the Abattoir” seems on Her younger grownup Mythos novel, Summoned, is out there from Tor Teen together with sequel Fathomless. She lives in Edgewood, a Victorian trolley automotive suburb of Windfall, Rhode Island, uncomfortably close to Joseph Curwen’s underground laboratory.