book reviews Fantasy Featured Games Horror and Science Fiction main Official Reviews

Revolt in 2100 by Robert A Heinlein – SFFWorld

Revolt in 2100 by Robert A Heinlein – SFFWorld

This is the third assortment of Robert A. Heinlein’s so-called Future History. The primary was The Man Who Bought the Moon (reviewed right here), the second was The Inexperienced Hills of Earth (reviewed right here.)


By this third guide tales are being intentionally related together into Heinlein’s unfastened timeline framework, which developed from a conversation with Astounding editor John W. Campbell in 1941.

The tales in this edition are:

  • “If This Goes On—” (Expanded from the model originally revealed in Astounding Science Fiction, February & March 1940)
  • “Coventry” (1940; his seventh brief story revealed, originally revealed in Astounding Science Fiction, July 1940)
  • “Misfit” (1939; his second revealed story, originally revealed in Astounding Science Fiction, November 1939)
  • Afterword: “Concerning Stories Never Written”


The original 1953 hardback also included, for the first time, a replica of Heinlein’s Future Historical past chart and a Foreword by fellow writer Henry Kuttner, “The Innocent Eye”.


Although Revolt is the third in this collection, a lot of the tales, in their unique publication state, date back to these included in The Man Who Bought the Moon. As such, they are early Heinlein writing, albeit with some revision, and in some instances, it exhibits.

Regardless of this guide having fewer tales, it’s the largest of the collection. To make the guide even greater, some later US editions included the novel Methusulah’s Youngsters (1958) as properly, which I’ll get to learn next. When it comes to context, this is able to make sense, as the novel, like many others of its time, was a ‘fix-up’ from what was revealed in the magazines – in this case, the three-part serial in Astounding from July-September 1941. Because of this Heinlein was writing it at about the identical time most of these different tales have been revealed, and it’s clearly talked about in the Future Historical past chart.

“If This Goes On—” begins this assortment with a bang, and is a superb start on the whole. In fifteen chapters and 133 pages, this novella tells of the ‘Crazy Years’, a time when a theocracy has taken maintain of the USA and the nation is in the despotic control of the infamous Nehemiah Scudder, who was talked about in Logic of Empire in The Green Hills of Earth. It is bleak, grim and chilling, I think reflecting, in half, the worldwide occasions of 1939-40. It questions Christian fundamentalism (although not all religions) via the eyes of John Lyle, initially a legate and guardsman in the Temple of the Lord in New Jerusalem, one of the elite guard of the Prophet Incarnate – never named right here, but presumably Scudder. Lyle falls in love with Sister Judith, one of many Virgins ‘ministering’ to the Prophet, and consequently Lyle turns into part of the resistance in order to engineer her escape from the prophet’s palace.

The middle part of the novel is what happens when Lyle, vulnerable to being found, additionally escapes the temple.  He becomes a courier, working as a sleeper agent with an unknown message buried deep in his unconscious by hypnosis.  As Lyle runs away, in this part of the novella we see by means of Lyle the results and actuality of dwelling in a theocratic state – extreme authority management, fixed surveillance, pretend information, and propaganda.

The conclusion of the story includes Lyle working on the secret headquarters of the resistance, finally turning into part of the revolution towards Scudder.  Displaying all those conventional Heinlein values of honour, loyalty and ‘doing the right thing’ even at a personal value, the top shouldn’t actually be a surprise.

Despite its age, “If This Goes On…” is a sobering story, and even in its first type surprisingly mature for a narrative written by a author at this level barely beginning his career*. (It have to be stated that this model is expanded from roughly 33 000 phrases to 57 300, almost double its unique length from the original two-part Astounding serial.) While there are weak factors (the initial romance is unconvincing, as most of its 1930’s contemporaries have been), the overall impression is of an journey story with a message, a salutary reminder of what can happen in a dictatorship state. Initially revealed in 1940, as the Germans have been occupying Western Europe, it’s perhaps as relevant now in 2018 as it was almost 80 years ago.

*It might be value reading the original model, which exhibits how far Heinlein had progressed as a author from 1939-1953. (Half One is HERE, Half Two is HERE.) The second 1953 model is extra complicated and extra nuanced, but has misplaced a little bit of its innocence and allure. (For example, in the unique 1940 model at the finish John Lyle leaves the army after the Revolution, marries Judith and takes up the profession his covert character managed undercover, in textiles.)   In the second edition we have now more sex – Judith in the unique first meets John when the Prophet is discussing taxes, in the 1953 version her position is extra physical. There’s a scene of nude bathing in underground caves that applies Freudian imagery with a broad brush, to symbolise John’s religious and bodily awakening.

My unique NEL paperback cowl.

In this Future Historical past, Coventry and Misfit are tales set after “If This Goes On…”, when society has grow to be more secular. Both tales are concerning the consequences of this time, when each of the story’s protagonists reject the society they reside in, to forge their own future.  Each are value reading, though not as memorable as the primary novel/novella.

Coventry (Hyperlink HERE) is a story of David MacKinnon, a professor in the time after “If This Goes On…”, who, after punching a person who offended him, is taken to trial. The State convicts him for being capable of morally judging his fellow citizens and feeling justified in personally correcting and punishing their lapses. He is given two decisions as punishment – psychological readjustment or exile to Coventry, a spot separated from the rest of the world by a force-field barrier. Clearly, MacKinnon chooses Coventry.

The world of Coventry is, in actuality, the world in micro-cosm and cut up into totally different elements. Like Scudder’s theocracy earlier than it, the so-called ‘New America’ is definitely corrupt, counting on taxing its residents into submission. The “Free State” is even worse, a dictatorship, typically at odds with New America. Within the hills to the North of New America lies ”The Angels”, what is left of Scudder’s theocracy with a new Prophet. When MacKinnon and his jail buddy Fader Magee discover a plot by New America to invade the world outdoors Coventry, the story turns into more conventional Libertarian fare, and it ends as you may anticipate, albeit slightly abruptly and conveniently.

Initially this was Heinlein’s seventh revealed story, revealed after The Roads Should Roll but before Blowups Happen. It’s a surprise to me in that it’s really a political story, which I tended to assume came later in his career. (Admittedly, this was earlier than For Us, the Dwelling was found.) Yes, there’s an adventure story in there, nevertheless it’s principally political diatribe wrapped up in a romp, and one without the talents of the later Heinlein to totally make it work.

I feel probably the most fascinating point for me is that whilst Coventry appears to extol the virtues of the individual (as “rugged individualists”) in occasions of stress, Heinlein additionally exhibits us the results of the Second Revolution and does not like the whole lot he sees. Regardless of all the sacrifice shown in “If This Goes On—”, this ‘brave new world’ has set itself as much as repeat the mistakes of the previous and probably find yourself worse than earlier than. It’s a reminder that when the warfare is gained, the battle must continue, in order to take care of order and enhance what has occurred earlier than. A message perhaps applicable for 1940, when the globe was heading in the direction of World Conflict II.


Great Signet cowl

Misfit (hyperlink HERE) is a story of Andrew Jackson Libby, nicknamed ‘Pinky’.  After an overtly political tale, this is Heinlein in a more typical mode, an adventure story of an outsider who has been sequestered to work and manages to resist the challenge. It’s slightly proto-Starship Troopers, although informed in the second individual moderately than the first, of how younger men will modify asteroids into habitats that may help future exploration into area. Libby is a red-headed, untrained misfit with a gift for Mathematics and, in the standard Heinlein method, is shown to be a hero.

I noticed it as one other story that’s Heinlein’s call-to-arms, written at a time of approaching world warfare to point out that the longer term might be vibrant. The minor level that Pinky is a redhead will develop into more necessary in later books. We’ll meet the character once more (albeit briefly) in Methuselah’s Youngsters and The Cat Who Walked Via Partitions.

Lastly, there’s a short but intriguing postscript written by Heinlein lengthy after the tales have been originally revealed in 1953, explaining how the Future History tales happened and the way they tied together. Most apparently, he tells us of tales he might (or might not) write to fill in the gaps of the History.

Three are talked about right here. Firstly, The Sound of his Wings, initially deliberate to start out shortly earlier than Logic of Empire (in The Green Hills of Earth) and increasing beyond Logic’s timespan, would have informed of the adolescence and rise to energy of Nehemiah Scudder, the First Prophet of ‘If This Goes On…’ Heinlein right here, writing in 1953, suggests that the story would have been ‘down-beat’, and that there’s sufficient of that in the day by day headlines to benefit adding more.

The second unfinished story, Eclipse, would have informed the story of the breakaway and independence of Mars and Venus, adopted by ‘the cessation of interplanetary travel.’ It’s parallels with the American Revolution and the worldwide breakup of colonialism is deliberate. Heinlein stated that it will in all probability by no means get written because he had since written two novels following comparable themes, not sure by the restrictions of a Future Historical past.

Lastly, The Stone Pillow would have been concerning the progress of an underground counterculture main as much as the Second American Revolution. Like The Sound of his Wings, it was felt by Heinlein to be too downbeat to be value pursuing further, although there are clearly parts of this in ‘If This Goes On…’  and Coventry.

Kindle cowl

All of those are intriguing ideas, but I do feel that Heinlein might have been right not to develop them extra.

So: in summary, how do these stories hold up? Though the stories have been first revealed in 1939-40, they have been, in fact, not simply obtainable to reread till this assortment was revealed in 1953, with enlargement and revision. How does this collection fit in context? Nicely, 1953 was also the yr of Starman Jones (reviewed here) and the gathering Task in Eternity, (containing the four novellas Gulf (1949), Elsewhen (1941), Misplaced Legacy (1941) and Jerry Was A Man (1947)) before The Star Beast in 1954 (reviewed HERE).

Of the three collections that make up the history, this is maybe the weakest of the three, although unusually, it is the largest.  Revolt in 2100 is value studying only for the primary novella alone, though Heinlein’s feedback on the end intriguingly fill in a number of the gaps. (I’ve additionally noted that For Us, the Dwelling, Heinlein’s first novel revealed after his demise, also mentions Scudder, so have added that to my studying record, as maybe re-reading the Future Historical past’s final hurrah, Methuselah’s Youngsters.)

Briefly, then, are these tales value studying? While they’re undoubtedly “of a time”, they do have their deserves and their issues. These tales, in contrast with the later materials, do show much less complexity and elegance, but they are noticeably displaying the writing voice that the writer was cultivating, even in these early years.

Despite the naivety, maybe more importantly they show much less of the weather that Heinlein’s critics are unhappy with in his later work. They are value studying, if not solely to point out how essential Heinlein was in the 1940’s and ‘50’s.  Of all the work written by RAH, the Future Historical past collection exhibit the writer’s strengths, with less of the weaknesses. (For instance, examine this with I Will Worry No Evil, Time Enough For Love or To Sail the Sundown.) For all of their issues, if you would like a flavour of the writer’s greatest, I might steer you more in the direction of this early work than the later ones.

Revolt in 2100 by Robert A. Heinlein

First revealed in 1953

This edition NEL 1977

ISBN: 978 zero 450 03585 2

317 pages

Evaluate by Mark Yon